A lease looks cheaper every month — until you add up the years. See the real total cost of leasing forever versus financing and owning, over however long you actually keep a car.
| Buy | Lease |
|---|
A lease almost always wins the monthly-payment contest, and that's exactly why dealerships love steering you toward it. You're only paying for the depreciation during the lease term, not the whole car — so of course it's less per month. The catch is what happens at the end: you hand the keys back, own nothing, and start a brand-new payment on your next lease. Do that on repeat and you have a car payment for the rest of your life. Financing costs more per month, but every payment is buying you a piece of an asset you'll eventually own outright.
The moment buying pulls ahead is the month you make your last loan payment. From then on, the owner drives for $0 a month while the leaser is still paying — and still paying, and still paying. Push the slider above out to eight or ten years and watch the gap explode. That's not an accident; it's the whole math of ownership. The longer you keep a car, the more lopsided it gets in favor of buying.
This isn't a trick question with only one answer. Leasing is a legitimate choice if you want a new car every two or three years, you drive low miles (leases cap you, usually around 10,000–12,000 a year, with steep per-mile penalties over that), you like staying under warranty the whole time, or you write the car off as a business expense. You're essentially renting convenience and predictability. Just go in knowing you're trading long-term dollars for short-term flexibility — not getting a "deal."
The buy side estimates your car's resale value at the end of the period and subtracts it, because a paid-off car is money you can get back — that's the equity a lease never gives you. It uses a standard depreciation curve (a car keeps very roughly a quarter to a third of its value after eight years). The lease side assumes you keep leasing to stay in a car for the whole period, paying the drive-off cost again with each new lease. Real quotes vary, so plug in the actual numbers from a dealer to make it exact — the conclusion rarely changes.
Now that you know what the car costs, see what it costs to drive — per trip, per mile, and per year.
Open the fuel calculator →